Showing posts with label Scythe. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scythe. Show all posts

Saturday, November 17, 2012

Review: Scythe Katana 4

Small footprintDecent performance considering sizePoor mounting arrangementNot as good as a larger cooler

Fans 120mm and larger dominate the enthusiast and overclocking market. What hope, then, for the plucky little Scythe Katana 4 and its 92mm fan?

Scythe is an experienced outfit and this is the fourth version of the compact Katana, so if it doesn't deliver, it's probably time for the towel-tossing to begin.

As before, the latest Katana is smaller than your average high performance cooler in just about all directions, measuring nearly 100mm square and 143mm in height.

The upshot of this is that you're unlikely to find a remotely mainstream ATX motherboard or case that won't jive with the Katana 4.It's not going to tussle for space with your RAM or argue with your graphics card.

Scythe has also tried to improve cooling performance via an increase in the overall cooling area provided by the aluminium fin stack while maintaining the triple copper heat pipes of its predecessor. What you make of the results will depend on your expectations.

If you're looking to equal the performance and noise levels of a larger 120mm cooler, it ain't gonna happen. Even so, at stock clocks, it's a nice cooler that keeps peak operating temps around 50°C, which is far from shabby.

That said, we're less keen on the mounting arrangement, which involves those ghastly press-in clips in conjunction with Intel boards (except LGA 2011 boards). We've never been confident they deliver even force across the surface of the CPU package.

Tuesday, November 13, 2012

Review: Scythe Mugen 3 Rev. B

Good performanceQuiet operationDecent price

Maintaining the low noise levels and temps, while upping the compatibility ante. That's the plan for the third version (revision B, don't you know) of Scythe's Mugen 120mm cooler.

That means refined airflow and Scythe's Slipstream noise-optimised 120mm fan. The result is a cooler with a rated noise that kicks off below 27.4dBA, even if the maximum noise breaches the 30dBA barrier.

Other upsides include some of the nicest assembly instructions we've seen, with a proper annotated key to all the parts. Joy!

Ironically, however, and against Scythe's apparent intention, what the Mugen 3 isn't is easy to plop into any case or hook up to any motherboard you care to mention. It's still a big thing. Large enough, in fact, that it's only possible to fit it in a single orientation to avoid fisticuffs with the DIMM slots. That's as intended, and not an issue, but it does give you an idea of the girth of the cooling stack.

Still, Scythe's effort hasn't been for naught. Across the board, the operating temps are competitive. At stock clocks, only the even larger Zalman CNPS14X slightly edges it. Likewise, it's just a measly degree behind the best with our Core i5-2500K test chip clocked up to 5GHz.

Which sounds dandy until you consider that Enermax's ETS-T40 is one of those 'best' coolers. And it's cheaper. And it's smaller and easier to fit. That means that, as good as the Mugen 3 is, it doesn't get the nod.